| 2024 | Emma | Closurdo | Eastern Kentucky |
| 2024 | Reese | Collins | Buffalo |
| 2024 | Hailee | Mack | Missouri |
| 2024 | Charlotte | Moriarty | Xavier |
| 2023 | Lauren | Bohn | Depauw |
| 2023 | Nya | Bunton | Texas |
| 2023 | Kelli | Conder | Walsh |
| 2023 | Gabby | Dean | Illinois |
| 2023 | Lauren | Dinunzi | Ohio Domincan |
| 2023 | Olivia | Fish | Wake Forest |
| 2023 | Alyssa | Furlong | Binghamton |
| 2023 | Gabrielle | Gerry | South Carolina |
| 2023 | Sydney | Helmers | Texas |
| 2023 | Olivia | Hellman | Campbellsville |
| 2023 | Elle | Jackson | East Carolina |
| 2023 | Savannah | Jolly | Cumberlands |
| 2023 | Lainee | Mack | Flagler |
| 2023 | Ava | Norris | Florida Atlantic |
| 2023 | Cecelia | Roberts | Transylvania |
| 2023 | Georgia | Simon | Aurora |
| 2023 | Lydia | Stephens | Eastern Kentucky |
| 2023 | Alexis | Strong | Abilene Christian |
| 2023 | Whitney | Woodrow | Fordham |
| 2022 | KJ | Baker | Spalding |
| 2022 | Grace | Brooker | DePaul |
| 2022 | Joy | Carstanjen | Kenyon |
| 2022 | Izzy | Carter | Alabama at Birmingham |
| 2022 | Emma | DeSensi | Colorado |
| 2022 | Ellie | Fox | West Georgia |
| 2022 | Riley | Kamer | DePauw |
| 2022 | Julia | McNeely | James Madison |
| 2022 | Alex | O'Conner | Transylvania |
| 2022 | Addison | Poehner | Furman |
| 2022 | Katie | Pogue | Southwest Baptist |
| 2022 | Emily | Ready | South Alabama |
| 2022 | Madison | Rice-Locket | Memphis |
| 2022 | Mia | Saenz | Tennessee-Martin |
| 2022 | Tess | Schrenger | Tampa |
| 2022 | Audrey | Whitworth | Kentucky |
| 2022 | Sydney | Williams | Anderson |
| 2022 | Brenna | Wyman | UConn |
| 2021 | Anna | Blumeier | Cumberlands |
| 2021 | Jayda | Branch | Spalding |
| 2021 | Kelsey | Brangers | Western Kentucky |
| 2021 | Caroline | Cermack | Miami (OH) |
| 2021 | Alyssa | Eaton | Bellarmine |
| 2021 | Carly | Furlong | UConn |
| 2021 | Macy | Graves | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2021 | Julianna | Hakel | Transylvania |
| 2021 | Crew | Hoffmeier | Virginia Commonwealth |
| 2021 | Kayden | Holcomb | Transylvania |
| 2021 | Isabella | Hughes | Georgetown College |
| 2021 | Sequoia | Hunt | Northern Kentucky |
| 2021 | Miranda | Jantzen | Bryant |
| 2021 | Lane | Jenkins | Kentucky |
| 2021 | Fallan | Lanham | Auburn |
| 2021 | Davis | Makayla | Transylvania |
| 2021 | Lucy | Malone | Coastal Carolina |
| 2021 | Bree | Martin | St. Johns |
| 2021 | Karly | McNeil | Georgetown College |
| 2021 | Mykole | Morgan | Mercer |
| 2021 | Madilyn | O'Toole | James Madison |
| 2021 | Elizabeth | Papalia | Amherst |
| 2021 | Emmeri | Roberts | Chicago |
| 2021 | Nevaeh | Scott | South Alabama |
| 2021 | Reese | Speed | Georgetown College |
| 2021 | Kaitlyn | Stivers | Thomas More |
| 2021 | Jaymison | Summers | Marian |
| 2021 | Makenna | Walker | Georgetown College |
| 2021 | Jenny | Wessling | High Point |
| 2021 | Kate | Whittle | Berry |
| 2021 | Caitlyn | Woodard | Transylvania |
| 2020 | Sophie | Ball | Campbellsville |
| 2020 | LaTeah | Barrett | Indiana University - East |
| 2020 | Kristen | Clemons | Belmont |
| 2020 | Olivia | Cunningham | Christian Brothers |
| 2020 | Anna | DeBeer | Louisville |
| 2020 | Josie | Disponette | St. Mary's San Antonio |
| 2020 | Brandy | Eisenback | Indiana University - East |
| 2020 | Taylor | Eisert | Middle Tennessee State |
| 2020 | Claire | Fuller | Jacksonville State |
| 2020 | Sydney | Goodrich | Glenville State |
| 2020 | Hannah | Holland | Spalding |
| 2020 | Lexi | Lester | Cumberlands |
| 2020 | Hannah | McGill | Campbellsville |
| 2020 | Katie | McKune | Eastern Kentucky |
| 2020 | Chloe | Mingus | Middle Tennessee State |
| 2020 | Savannah | Neal | Naval Academy |
| 2020 | Rylee | Rader | Ohio State |
| 2020 | Bella | Rough | Thomas More |
| 2020 | Morgan | Rutledge | Austin Peay |
| 2020 | Alexis | Striegel | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2020 | Samantha | Walton | Transylvania |
| 2020 | Riley | Winslow | Marshall |
| 2019 | Emily | Arnold | Bellarmine |
| 2019 | Sophie | Ball | Campbellsville |
| 2019 | Karly | Basham | Washington State |
| 2019 | Lilly | Bivens | Nicholls State |
| 2019 | Skylar | Boom | Tennessee Tech |
| 2019 | Natalie | Brutscher | Walsh |
| 2019 | Anna | Burke | Northern Kentucky |
| 2019 | Maggie | Burns | Daemen |
| 2019 | Myleah | Carter | Norfolk State |
| 2019 | Sydney | Colvin | Bellarmine |
| 2019 | Kiah | Cox | Transylvania |
| 2019 | Bobbi | Crosby | Fisk |
| 2019 | Alexis | Dirckson | Spalding |
| 2019 | Josie | Grace-Mudd | Centre |
| 2019 | Alexa | Hendricks | Louisville |
| 2019 | Scout | Hoffmeier | USC Upstate |
| 2019 | Madison | Jennings | Union |
| 2019 | Mallory | Lipski | Fordham |
| 2019 | Callie | Martin | Wright State |
| 2019 | Emma | Monks | Michigan State |
| 2019 | Lauren | Myrick | Mississippi State |
| 2019 | Camille | Nazor | Duke |
| 2019 | Kylie | Newby | Indiana State |
| 2019 | MaryAnn | O'Toole | Xavier |
| 2019 | Carissa | Reyes | Bellarmine |
| 2019 | Allie | Simpson | Niagara |
| 2019 | Sara | Tino | Spalding |
| 2019 | Lexi | Uhrhan | Mercer |
| 2019 | Brenna | Valsted | Adelphi |
| 2018 | Bella | Bowman | George Washington |
| 2018 | Myana | Carter | Oakland |
| 2018 | Allyson | Cathey | Penn State |
| 2018 | Jordyn | Chenault | Bethune-Cookman |
| 2018 | Julia | Dailey | Bellarmine |
| 2018 | Rachel | DeMarcus | Louisville |
| 2018 | Lexie | Fisher | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2018 | Payton | Frederick | Cincinnati |
| 2018 | Katie | Hall | Centre |
| 2018 | Kayla | Kaiser | Georgia Tech |
| 2018 | Jennie | Malone | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2018 | Peyton | McClinton | UNC - Asheville |
| 2018 | Bailey | Roszman | Bellarmine |
| 2018 | Alexis | Smith | Lindsey Wilson |
| 2018 | Jenna | Story | Wright State |
| 2018 | Alli | Stumler | Kentucky |
| 2018 | Mia | Swearingon | Morehead State |
| 2018 | Alexis | Triplett | Lipscomb |
| 2017 | Jacqueline | Askin | Bowling Green |
| 2017 | Emily | Azzara | Cincinnati |
| 2017 | Lauryn | Bennett | Rice |
| 2017 | Ana | Crocket | USC Aiken |
| 2017 | Megan | Crush | American |
| 2017 | Nadia | Diuedonne | Western Kentucky |
| 2017 | Kaelin | Gentile | Northern Kentucky |
| 2017 | Alexis | Hamilton | Louisville |
| 2017 | Paige | Hammons | Florida |
| 2017 | Taylor | Hodges | Morehead State |
| 2017 | Nina | Korfhage | Austin Peay |
| 2017 | Maddie | Lentz | Radford |
| 2017 | Brooke | Moore | Austin Peay |
| 2017 | Kristen | O'Toole | Bellarmine |
| 2017 | Anna | Palmer | Memphis |
| 2017 | Courtney | Pierce | Marian |
| 2017 | Sierra | Rayzor | Samford |
| 2017 | Brooke | Rogers | Siena |
| 2017 | Isabel | Salameh | Bellarmine |
| 2017 | Elizabeth | Stigger | Transylvania |
| 2017 | Cassidy | Thielen | Earlham |
| 2017 | Madelyn | Weber | Northern Kentucky |
| 2016 | Kendall | Barrett | Bellarmine |
| 2016 | Elizabeth | Boyce | Bellarmine |
| 2016 | China | Brown | Bellarmine |
| 2016 | Chandler | Clark | Morehead State |
| 2016 | Alyssa | Cosgrove | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2016 | Lee Ann | Cunningham | Rice |
| 2016 | Olivia | Grass | Georgetown College |
| 2016 | Allison | Gregory | Florida |
| 2016 | Lindsey | Howell | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2016 | Mikaila | Humphrey | Southern Indiana |
| 2016 | Gwyn | Jones | Auburn |
| 2016 | Kaitlin | Knoop | Midway University |
| 2016 | Teyah | Leinenbach | Bellarmine |
| 2016 | Savannah | Moss | Campbellsville |
| 2016 | Shelby | Olsen | Northern Kentucky |
| 2016 | Kara | Shacklette | Wofford |
| 2016 | Madalon | Simpson | Virginia Commonwealth |
| 2016 | Sydney | Welch | George Washington |
| 2015 | Katie | Adams | Bellarmine |
| 2015 | Krista | Boesing | Samford |
| 2015 | Jennifer | Buckman | Transylvania |
| 2015 | Miranda | Elpers | Chattanooga |
| 2015 | Amanda | Frank | Southern Indiana |
| 2015 | Brooklyn | Garrison | Union |
| 2015 | Lexie | Hamrick | North Carolina |
| 2015 | Emily | Holland | Ball State |
| 2015 | Grace | James | Pennsylvania |
| 2015 | Jordyn | Kuchenbrod | Bellarmine |
| 2015 | Lydia | Lange | Bellarmine |
| 2015 | Alexis | Lete | George Washington |
| 2015 | Kenzie | Maloney | Nebraska |
| 2015 | Elizabeth | Mann | Life |
| 2015 | Aurryella | Mason | Bellarmine |
| 2015 | Mallory | Sacre | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| 2015 | Molly | Sauer | Louisville |
| 2015 | Abby | Schlaug | Bellarmine |
| 2015 | McKenzie | Watson | Kentucky |
| 2015 | Bailey | Wheatley | Wright State |
| 2014 | Cassidy | Anderson | Georgia |
| 2014 | Rachel | Andrews | Union |
| 2014 | Ashley | Askin | Georgia Tech |
| 2014 | Alyssa | Cavanaugh | Western Kentucky |
| 2014 | Courtney | Crable | Auburn |
| 2014 | Hayden | Daily | Bellarmine |
| 2014 | Danielle | Densford | Wofford |
| 2014 | Sydney | Engle | Western Kentucky |
| 2014 | Alexa | Filley | Auburn |
| 2014 | Jessica | Thornton | Wright State |
| 2014 | Jessica | Lucas | Western Kentucky |
| 2014 | Mikaela | Milam | Samford |
| 2014 | Hannah | Moore | Wayne State |
| 2014 | Caitlyn | Pfaat | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2014 | Sabrina | Schlueger | Tusculum |
| 2014 | Stacy | Spalding | St. Thomas |
| 2014 | Lauren | Tutwiler | Florida Golf Coast |
| 2014 | Korissa | Waelbroeck | IUPUI |
| 2013 | London | Ackermann | Georgia Tech |
| 2013 | Andrea | Amettis | Tusculum |
| 2013 | Abby | Bialczak | Brescia College |
| 2013 | Rachel | Boesing | Asbury College |
| 2013 | Haley | Garr | Wright State |
| 2013 | Gabbi | Greenwald | Samford |
| 2013 | Kaelin | Grimes | Western Kentucky |
| 2013 | Katherine | Hagan | Centre |
| 2013 | Catlin | Lilly | Memphis |
| 2013 | Maya | McClendon | Arizona State |
| 2013 | Georgia | O'Connell | Western Kentucky |
| 2013 | Taylor | Paulson | St. Louis |
| 2013 | Madison | Tinder | Bellarmine |
| 2012 | Chelsea | Bowles | Tennessee-Martin |
| 2012 | Audrey | Brown | Transylvania |
| 2012 | Amanda | Crask | Tennessee-Martin |
| 2012 | Rachel | Engle | Western Kentucky |
| 2012 | Katie | George | Louisville |
| 2012 | Lynsey | Hazelwood | Tennessee-Martin |
| 2012 | Sarah | Katz | American |
| 2012 | Jodie | Klein | Murray State |
| 2012 | Megan | Lipski | Buffalo (SUNY) |
| 2012 | Jamie | Wallace | University of Indianapolis |
| 2012 | Dallas | Zimmerman | Tennessee-Martin |
| 2011 | Taylor | Allgeier | Eastern Kentucky |
| 2011 | Morgen | Clayton | Murray State |
| 2011 | Hannah | English | Ohio Northern |
| 2011 | Tiffany | Filburn | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2011 | Claire | Gerwig | Western Michigan |
| 2011 | Mechael | Guess | Pittsburgh |
| 2011 | Jeni | Houser | Notre Dame |
| 2011 | Natalie | Keck | Houston |
| 2011 | Paige | Moore | Union |
| 2011 | Jackie | Napper | Kentucky |
| 2011 | Kristen | Newberry | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2011 | Jaclyn | Ohlmann | Bellarmine |
| 2011 | Laura | Purcell | Loyola |
| 2011 | Courtney | Robison | Louisville |
| 2011 | Katelyn | Shoemaker | Wittenberg |
| 2011 | Jennifer | Smith | Indiana |
| 2011 | Meaghen | Tompkins | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2011 | Casey | Wilkerson | Spalding |
| 2010 | Katie | Ash | Transylvania |
| 2010 | Haley | Barnes | Lindsey Wilson |
| 2010 | Meghan | Bowers | Transylvania |
| 2010 | Laura | Der | Marshall |
| 2010 | Krista | Gibson | Bellarmine |
| 2010 | Madison | Hardy | Miami of Ohio |
| 2010 | Melanie | Hicks | Indiana |
| 2010 | Lexie | Krall | Rhodes |
| 2010 | Allison | May | Tennessee Tech |
| 2010 | Deja | McClendon | Penn State |
| 2010 | Jordan | Owens | Vincennes |
| 2010 | Ashley | Potts | Western Kentucky |
| 2010 | Lindsey | Roth | Morehead State |
| 2010 | Latosha | Scott | Jackson State |
| 2010 | Alexis | Smith | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2010 | Melanie | Stutsman | Western Kentucky |
| 2010 | Desirre | Wilkerson | Kentucky |
| 2009 | Anna Lee | Abell | Georgetown College |
| 2009 | Roxanne | Acree | Indiana University - Southeast |
| 2009 | Lexi | Bauer | Samford |
| 2009 | Whitney | Craven | Mississippi |
| 2009 | Kasey | Elswick | Tennessee-Martin |
| 2009 | Jenna | Foushee | Centre |
| 2009 | Emily | Hayden | Cincinnati |
| 2009 | Stephanie | Klefot | Kentucky |
| 2009 | Ryanne | Milligan | Marshall |
| 2009 | Arielle | Milner | Georgetown College |
| 2009 | Catherine | Neumann | West Georgia |
| 2009 | Brooke | Porter | Union |
| 2009 | Ellie | Roberson | Morehead State |
| 2009 | Sarah | Rogers | Western Kentucky |
| 2009 | Katy | Schad | Marshall |
| 2009 | Andrea | Taylor | Lindsey Wilson |
| 2009 | Kaitlin | Young | Bellarmine |
| 2008 | Holly | Allgeier | Niagara |
| 2008 | Colleen | Belak | Chicago |
| 2008 | Shannon | Cahill | Campbellsville |
| 2008 | Sloane | Donhoff | Michigan |
| 2008 | Ashley | Estes | Austin Peay |
| 2008 | Elizabeth | Goodin | Georgetown College |
| 2008 | Abby | Hall | Embry-Riddle |
| 2008 | Lauren | Harkins | Jacksonville State |
| 2008 | Kaitlynn | James | Nebraska |
| 2008 | Samantha | James | Campbellsville |
| 2008 | Kelsey | Luckett | Georgetown College |
| 2008 | Carrie | Minogue | Western Carolina |
| 2008 | Stephanie | Riley | Alabama |
| 2008 | Gwen | Rucker | Louisville |
| 2008 | Kayleah | Sauer | Murray State |
| 2008 | Morgan | Springer | Mississippi |
| 2008 | Maci | Wachtel | Louisville |
| 2008 | Austin | Ziegler | Bellarmine |
| 2007 | Emily | Beckman | Bellarmine |
| 2007 | Rebecca | Bloemer | Wingate |
| 2007 | Kirstie | Brangers | Morehead State |
| 2007 | Kaitlin | Craven | Morehead State |
| 2007 | Emily | Galbraith | St. Louis |
| 2007 | Kaitlan | Harris | Bellarmine |
| 2007 | Sara | Hayden | Murray State |
| 2007 | Ashton | Hupman | Centre |
| 2007 | Sue | Jacobi | Ohio |
| 2007 | Hayley | Koetter | Indiana |
| 2007 | Leah | Meffert | Tennessee Tech |
| 2007 | Linsey | Schmalz | Bellarmine |
| 2007 | Hannah | Sullivan | Ball State |
| 2006 | Kirstin | Distler | Austin Peay |
| 2006 | Lindsey | Gould | Western Kentucky |
| 2006 | Whitney | Haynes | Campbellsville |
| 2006 | Christina | Kaelin | Notre Dame |
| 2006 | Morgan | Kennedy | Spalding |
| 2006 | Lucie | Klein | Morehead State |
| 2006 | Emily | Logsdon | Campbellsville |
| 2006 | Rachel | Long | Spalding |
| 2006 | Renee | Netherton | Campbellsville |
| 2006 | Michelle | O'Bryan | Bellarmine |
| 2006 | Kelly | Potts | Western Kentucky |
| 2006 | Whitney | Roth | St. Louis |
| 2006 | BriAnne | Sauer | Kentucky |
| 2006 | Kristina | Schoo | Morehead State |
| 2006 | Stephanie | Steele | Butler |
| 2006 | Whitney | Wright | Iona |
| 2005 | Megan | Argabright | Western Kentucky |
| 2005 | Kristy | Elswick | Southern Illinois |
| 2005 | Mindy | Flynn | Tennessee |
| 2005 | Stephanie | Lynch | Purdue |
| 2005 | Whitney | McCory | Western Kentucky |
| 2005 | Julia | Noe | Western Kentucky |
| 2005 | Erin | Peak | Morehead State |
| 2005 | Alisa | Pierce | Kentucky |
| 2005 | Lauren | Schutte | Eastern Illinois |
| 2005 | Whitney | West | Wingate |
| 2004 | Amanda | Alvey | Bellarmine |
| 2004 | Stephanie | Cahill | Marshall |
| 2004 | Ali | Christian | Western Kentucky |
| 2004 | Mallory | Eikenberry | Eastern Kentucky |
| 2004 | Ellen | Heintzman | Notre Dame |
| 2004 | Amy | Johnson | Morehead State |
| 2004 | Tara | Langley | Mississippi |
| 2004 | Julie | Pierce | Indiana |
| 2004 | Laura | Reilly | Rhodes |
| 2003 | Kate | Bean | Toledo |
| 2003 | Amanda | Bowling | Union |
| 2003 | Jenni | Casper | Kentucky |
| 2003 | Ashley | Deignan | Western Kentucky |
| 2003 | Erica | Hardy | Western Kentucky |
| 2003 | Callaway | Logan | Samford |
| 2003 | Marisa | Main | Ohio State |
| 2003 | Ashley | Meffert | Binghamton |
| 2003 | Sarah | Moore | University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee |
| 2003 | Julie | Purcell | Northwestern |
| 2003 | Jessica | Starck | Jacksonville State |
| 2003 | Shari | Weyer | Jacksonville State |
| 2002 | Sidney | Bennett | Pacific |
| 2002 | Jordan | Brightwell | Xavier |
| 2002 | Jennifer | Craven | Louisville |
| 2002 | Sarah | McClellan | Evansville |
| 2002 | Renee | Wachtel | Brescia College |
| 2001 | Natalie | Atzinger | Southern Indiana |
| 2001 | Kathleen | Beck | Dayton |
| 2001 | Mary Nell | Bennett | Mississippi |
| 2001 | Amanda | Cecil | Western Kentucky |
| 2001 | Beth | Cowley | LSU |
| 2001 | Jill | Ender | Union |
| 2001 | Katie | Hall | UNCC |
| 2001 | Kenna | Milner | Alabama |
| 2001 | Addie | Thiry | Rutgers |
| 2001 | Diana | Zipp | Morehead State |
| 2000 | Kimberly | Cockerel | Xavier |
| 2000 | Candace | Cogan | Louisville |
| 2000 | Lillie | Danielle | Bellarmine |
| 2000 | Benny | Flynn | Louisville |
| 2000 | Fox | Jennifer | Morehead State |
| 2000 | Tracy | May | Western Kentucky |
| 2000 | Shelly | O'Bryan | Illinois |
| 2000 | Jennifer | Pierce | Embry-Riddle |
| 2000 | Sara | Taylor | Northern Kentucky |
